|
Sophie Bishop - Physiotherapist - September 2001
Background
My arrival at The Centre for Rehabilitation of the Paralysed (CRP) was
on the 12th of September 2001, for the duration of six months. My welcome
and orientation was provided by foreign members of the physiotherapy teaching
department. Information about how the Physiotherapy course was run and
hand over of my work was given by previous national lottery funded volunteer
John Wiseman.
The accommodation that I was allocated in the guest house was much better
than I expected and lived there for my first month at CRP. Following this
I moved into a flat that I shared with two other volunteers. This was
much more appropriate as I found that there was in fact little room for
lesson preparation and study in the guest house rooms. In both cases there
was a Ayah that provided very good Bangla food.
My initial impressions of Bangladesh
were that it was noisy and dirty (although nowhere near as bad as I had
expected), but that the people were very friendly. It was definitely good
to have a few days to settle in the oasis of CRP before venturing out
into the real world, where all your senses are attacked in one go!!! Everyone
that I met on my arrival were very friendly and welcoming, so it was easy
to feel quickly at home.
Role
During my six months of work at CRP I have undertaken several different
roles as a physiotherapy volunteer, mainly within the Bangladesh Health
Professions Institute. Initially I was allocated a lecturing role. This
included teaching a cardiopulmonary module to the second years and a management
module to the third years. I had already been given some information about
the content of the modules previous to my arrival in Bangladesh. This
was very helpful as it allowed me to bring some teaching resources from
the UK. My second role was to supervise 3 groups of students on cardiopulmonary
clinical placement.
Lecturing
The first week of my stay was mainly observational as I had never had
any previous teaching experience. I was quite amazed that only a small
amount of information was able to be taught in one lesson. The first few
lessons that I taught were quite difficult for me as I was very anxious
about the large number of pupils in the class (32 second years and 39
third years), the language barrier and the fact that my age was very close
to many of the students. In the end I realised that these things were
not so much of a problem as I had sufficient knowledge/ experience to
teach the students the basic principles of physiotherapy. In fact I think
being relatively newly qualified was an advantage as lecture formats and
content were fresh in my mind. The biggest battle was actually keeping
the students disciplined during a lesson as they often displayed inattentiveness
and immaturity towards learning.
Clinical placement
I started supervision of cardiopulmonary placement with the third year
students in November 2001. I took two groups of 9 and 10 students, for
five weeks each. The placement took place in Postgraduate Hospital, Dhaka,
where I supervised the students on the ICU and wards. There was no established
physiotherapy department in the hospital so it was a challenge to build
up good communication and a professional relationship with the doctors
and nurses. Most of the staff had no idea what chest physiotherapy was,
or the criteria for referral. I therefore arranged for the students to
do a formal presentation in front of the doctors. The hardest part of
supervision was the ratio of students to teacher. It was very difficult
to assess 9/10 students when they were working on nearly all wards in
the hospital. It certainly helped me to develop my organizational/ time
keeping skills!!!
The third placement I supervised was
for 4 weeks, with 11 second year students, in Dhaka Medical College Hospital.
This was actually harder than the first two placements for several reasons.
The conditions in the hospital were much worse, including overcrowding,
squalid conditions, and a much larger area to cover. The length of the
teaching day on placement was a bit shorter due to longer travelling time,
and more hospitals to drop off at on the way. This, added to an even larger
number of students who had no experience at all in a clinical setting,
meant that it was increasingly difficult to assess them. The students
themselves found it difficult because they all wanted to show me their
skills, but I was unable to give them enough individual time This was
not only a safety issue, but it also caused some tension within the group
as they became very competitive and were not working as a team.
Assessment of Students
This area was the most challenging for me. I found writing and marking
exams /coursework very difficult in the knowledge that the marks were
going towards the students final degree results and I was only two years
qualified myself. Having had no experience in this area, I was mainly
guided by my own memory of exams/ coursework. In the end I just set some
practice papers / homework to give me some experience with marking. This
helped to identify the students quality of written English and understanding
of the work I had already taught them. The main difficulty was knowing
to what level I was assessing them. Was I to assess them to the same level
as you would expect from physiotherapy students in the UK ? I still don't
have an official answer to this, but believe that it is impossible for
them to be the same standard. This is partly because of learning the course
in a second language, and partly because their previous education has
not taught them to think laterally or to take responsibility for their
own learning.
The other area of assessment was the
clinical placement. I have already mentioned the difficulty of student
numbers. The other main problem was that the placement assessment form
was very difficult to use. It was very subjective, and therefore made
it difficult to assess the students objectively. It also meant lack of
consistency of marking between different supervisors. The students themselves
seemed to expect very high marks for their placements. They did not really
appreciate the comments and feedback given about their performance which
was put in place to try and help them improve in the future.
Aerobics/ Circuit training Instructor
I was very involved in running fitness classes for the female students
during my evenings. Along with another foreign volunteer, I ran an alternating
programme of aerobics and circuit training. The classes were good fun
and helped me to develop a good relationship with the students, as well
keep me fit!! It was also a good way to teach some of the physio students
about basic exercise and stretching, which is something foreign volunteers
may just assume they know about.
Experience Gained
I have learnt many things from my time here in Bangladesh, and would recommend
the experience in CRP to others who wish to work in a developing country.
The lecturing and clinical supervision
has definitely helped me to develop my organizational and adaptation skills.
I feel that I have worked in many new areas which have required me to
take control and be assertive, even though I haven't had any previous
experience.
Teaching the theory of cardiopulmonary
has helped me to consolidate my knowledge of the subject, although I haven't
really been able to progress any of my own clinical skills. The management
module was a completely new area for me, but helped me to see how much
I had actually did know about the basics after only two years of clinical
practice.
My communication skills have certainly
been challenged, not only because of the language difficulties, but also
cultural differences between myself, students, staff and patients. I have
learnt many things from the students about how warm and welcoming the
people here in Bangladesh can be. I have also seen how difficult some
aspects of the culture can be to work with. Sometimes the poor communication,
time keeping and general self-discipline of other members of staff made
my job more difficult than it should have been.
The experience of working in a government
hospital here in Bangladesh is certainly something I will never forget.
I dearly hope that things improve in the future.
Overall my time in CRP has been very
fulfilling and enjoyable. This was helped by the general enthusiasm of
other volunteers I was fortunate enough to share my time with. I will
certainly think about returning in the future and hope that the physiotherapy
profession in Bangladesh will continue to grow and develop.
|